When Is It Time for a New Sofa?
I’ve been asking myself this question since we moved into our new house.
It’s not that we need a new sofa.
We actually have one sofa that’s not even being used.
But I would really like to replace the gray sofa which is in our family room with one of these.
I’ve blogged about my love for rolled arm sofas here and here.
The thing is the sofa I want to replace is only 4 years old and there is absolutely nothing wrong with it. For new readers, this is the couch I’m talking about as it used to sit in our old living room:
It’s well-made and would easily last many more years. So I feel kind of guilty about the whole thing. So what do you think? At one point is it okay to replace a perfectly good couch?
(Photos: 1.via Dress, Design, Decor 2.Notebook Mag 3.Domino 4.via Ill Seen, Ill Said 5.via My Favorite & My Best 6.Depadova 7.From the Right Bank)
Well the answer to that question depends entirely on (1) whether you propose to repurpose, reuse or upcycle current sofa or (2) give it to a needy friend or (3) sell it. I personally object to selling because I think you could find someone who deserves it. Once you get over those ethical issues, go for it.
Jane’s last post…Snakeskin and Rainbow Knits
I agree with the above comment, and if this has been in your head for 4 years… well then I think you've made up your mind
Margarita’s last post…You can never go back
I am in the same predicament as you. I totally want to replace our couch and a lot of our furniture for that matter.
The deal in our house is that whenever it's time for my husband to get some new technology, it's time for me to choose a new sofa…
pretty far west’s last post…hoping to be Aunt Dahlia
I say you get the sofa that you like which suits your home best. And then post about it on your blog because I'd really like to see what you purchase!!
Brismod’s last post…Paint thoughts
First of all, I heart your existing couch, so send it on over. Second, I just saw a one year old gorgeous white velvet tufted couch on Craig's List, with they ad saying they are remodeling. Four years is long compared to that time frame. As long as you don't throw it away, go for it. But did you think you were going to hear any no's from us?
A House and Home’s last post…Bedroom Inspiration
I'm in need of a new sofa soo bad! I've had this one too many years geesh!
tami’s last post…Glitz to Glamour- Milla Jovovich
new follower
and i am also OBSESSED with roll arm sofas. to die for!
sarah g’s last post…a few questions
I think that it's ok to replace a perfectly good sofa if you are changing decor styles. Then there's what to do with your sofa that's in perfect condition. There are 2 options:: 1) give the sofa away to a family that could use it, if your budget allows 2) Sell the sofa to help with the cost of the new one
I'm sure that you'll make the right decision
Ally, are you in my head??! I have been thinking the same thing. I REALLY want a rolled arm (Charles of London arm?) sofa but ours is perfectly serviceable. Mine is actually 10 years old but I actually still love the fabric. The arm are WAY too big though. Every time I look at it it makes me a little mad/sad. I will if you will!!
Aimee@ the Functiona’s last post…Tudor in the Afternoon
Oh yeah baby, those roll back numbers are pretty great. The time is NOW!
michelle’s last post…A Lovely Being
I really want a new sofa too, but there are other things to buy on my list before I get around to replacing anything else… An English roll-arm will definitely be my go-to choice when I finally do though!
Jane Flanagan’s last post…Paint it black
I'm dying for a new sofa too! Mine is only 4 years old but it's taken a beating. Love a classic roll arm sofa as well…so versatile!
xx Amanda
…my thinking is…if you can afford to replace your sofa and want to…do so…but…GIVE the other sofa away…that way two people have a new sofa…and you will feel wonderful…now if that second person had a respectable sofa and gave that sofa away…and then that person could….well…you know …that initial good feeling could end up going a long way…
Thanks for your feedback, everyone. I would definitely donate my old one. That's what I always do with old furniture.
pretty far west: I like that. If we applied that rule in our house, I'd have a new one every few months!
A House & Home: Hehe. Busted.
sarah g: Welcome!
Aimee: Deal!
I experience the same kind of struggle. I sometimes wonder if I get tired of things quickly because of the daily design stimulation. It seems like I fall in love with a new sofa weekly.
Such a relevant question for me as well. We have had the same blue couch in the family room for about 8 years…lately its been bothering me, but the problem is it was custom made…needed to be extra long, and I can’t justify a. getting rid of it…and b. ordering a new custom couch! Reupholstering might do the trick, but not sure.Good luck with your decision…love the last couch you posted! (and the image of your old living room is stunning!)
The Zhush’s last post…Summer Style Secrets- Rikshaw Design
I have been thinking the same thing about MY sofa which is only about 2 years old. So, I decided I would put it on CraigsList for a price I would be happy with and if it sells, then it's fate.
) I think on my 27th week on Craigslist. I just know one day it's gonna be fate! LOL! (Just kidding! But I am seriously about to do this exact thing! Already talked the husband into it.)
Ohhhhh, I say do a good deed(always makes you feel better about your decision) – give that one away – and go for it…can’t wait to see the new one!!
I have just ordered a new sofa. The one I am replacing is 6 yrs old and still good. I am having it recovered and using in another room. I cannot wait for the new one. Go for it.
I know exactly how you feel – although I can say that our couch is actually in a sad state (sigh…a white sofa is not the way to go when you have 2 dogs!!) It sounds like you just need to sell or giveaway yours and get one that would make you happier!! I'm thinking I need to take that advice too
Piper’s last post…does my bag look big in this
Are those Dutch landscapes I see?
angela | the painted’s last post…Tour of the Villa
Its time for a new couch whenever you're done with it. I subscribe to Macintosh's philosophy about how things in your home need to qualify under two categories – Practical AND Beautiful. They can't fulfill just one of the requirements… it must be both. And this means beautiful to YOU. I say Craigslist the old couch and go get your rolled arm dream sofa.
Sarah @ Maison Bohem’s last post…Baby Charlie
Ugh. I'm the last person to ask since I can't part with a sofa that legitimately needs to go.
If it's perfectly good, just sell it and buy one that better reflects your current style.
Bromeliad’s last post…Gone to the beach
If you are asking yourself this question, it is a sign you should get a new sofa. You will not be completely satisfied until you get it anyway – you will just keep asking yourself the question all over again until you buy it. Seriously, I know what I'm talking about.
Elli D.’s last post…Good Economic News
I'm about to buy a new sofa–there's no question for us that it's time for a new one–I've narowed it down to
two…
http://www.subtletyoftaste.blogspot.com
I love your sofa choices! The two-cushion, low rolled arm is so classic. I’d love a new sofa myself, but it’s just not in the budget. And there’s nothing *wrong* with my sofa either. But if you can sell what you have, or reuse in another room, or give to a worthy friend/cousin/etc, why not move on and get what you really want?
casey@loft&cottage’s last post…italian holiday- fini